Same book – Different title (a bookworm’s gripe)

I take umbrage when publishers, in their infinite wisdom, decide to rename a book which already has a perfectly acceptable title.  This has occurred with two of the most recent additions to my TBR.

I personally prefer the cover and title on the left. I’m not sure I would have even picked up the cover on the right.

again, I much prefer the cover and title on the left

Bookworms everywhere must have encountered this issue on more than one occasion. Readers who follow authors or series rather than titles, fall victim to this ploy regularly. I even purchased the same book twice because of it.  (Maybe that is their evil plan….)

Yes, I actually bought BOTH of these. I remember being SO excited that Peter Robinson had a new book out!

the decision to change the word ‘close’ to ‘alley’ for North American audiences is one that I find ludicrous. Anyone who follows Rankin’s Rebus wants to read #15 in the series regardless Also, they know what a ‘close’ is.

And don’t even get me started as to how much I hated it back when I was working as a library cataloger.  The library would have a book, patrons would place holds on that book. Then… another patron would hear about a book and place a ‘suggestion for purchase’. We’d buy that book and that title would generate holds being placed on it.  Then, when I catalogued it I would discover that book B was the SAME BOOK as book A.    URGHHHH! Our means of handling the problem was enough to give a cataloger nightmares.  We merged the two records together!!!!  GASP!  The reason for this was so that ALL the patrons who had holds on the book would be in one queue.  This in turn led to all sorts of mayhem, as when they came to pick up their book, they thought they were getting the wrong one!

This has happened a few times with one of my favorite authors, Louise Penny. On her website, Penny writes:
“The publishers did this not, as you might suspect, to be annoying but because they genuinely feel their readers respond to different titles.”

As I’ve mentioned, this practice of having one book with two different titles is a nightmare for library staff, and I expect, bookstore staff as well.  Some of the titles are so completely different that one would never guess it is the same book.  Some have common words and are changed only slightly.  What is the point? (other than to give library workers and bookstore employees grey hair)

It happened to one of my all-time favorite novels!

and one of my all-time favorite novelists, Ruth Rendell

and another of my favorite novelists, Fredrik Backman

It has happened with books by one of the world’s best-selling novelists!

It happened to the “Queen of Crime”

it has happened to Graham Greene

It has happened to Diana Gabaldon (“Outlander” is such a better title…)

and Sophie Hannah

and Jonathan Tropper

and Tess Gerritsen

and P.J. Tracey

and Richard Montanari

and Joseph Finder

and Diane Chamberlain

and the award-winning Lawrence Hill

along with myriad others that I don’t have time to name….

As a reader, what are YOUR thoughts on this issue?

Also, I’d love to hear what authors feel about this practice.

I’d love to hear your stories about books that are published under two different titles.  Post a comment!

Advertisements

About Fictionophile

Fiction reviewer ; Goodreads librarian. Retired library cataloger - more time to read! Loves books, gardening, and red wine. I have been a reviewer member of NetGalley since October 2013. I review titles offered by Edelweiss, and participate in blog tours with TLC Book Tours.
This entry was posted in ramblings & miscellanea and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

33 Responses to Same book – Different title (a bookworm’s gripe)

  1. Annika Perry says:

    I cannot believe I hadn’t realised this was happening!! Some of these I’ve known in one version but never of the other. It seems to be confusing practice at best! I too have a feeling I might have bought one of these books twice. – the Backman one but not got round to reading the other one yet! Grr. A fascinating post and yet again learning so much. Thank you so much for making me aware of this and I’ll keep my eyes peeled in future!

    Like

  2. Ugh I strongly dislike when this happens.. why?! Everything You Want Me to Be threw me for a loop earlier! Great post on a topic I have yet to see anyone else approach!

    Like

  3. Hi. I never knew about this practice. Publishing the same book with different titles? – – – it’s weird and nuts. I wonder how it works legally in regard to copyright laws et al. Nothing but confusion all around!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Cathy G says:

    This drives me absolutely mental! Great post

    Like

  5. skyecaitlin says:

    I was completely unaware of this, and you are so right to feel annoyed and thank you so much for giving us warning. The book should say clearly; ” Formerly entitled——by so and so.” I noticed that they also shake things up with using pseudonyms, as well.

    Like

  6. Great post! I’ve bought the same book a couple of times due to the title and cover being changed, it’s so frustrating. In some cases it feels deliberately misleadingly when there’s no mention at all that it was previously sold under a different title.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. carhicks says:

    I bought the Tess Gerritsen one twice because of this. Fortunately it was at a used book sale so it was not too costly. I did not realize it was that common.

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      I think it is a devious practice that should be outlawed. Is that too strong?? LOL Now I don’t feel so bad about buying Peter Robinson’s book twice.

      Like

  8. Nicole @ booksinked says:

    It did not happen to me at all. But wow, I can see why it is a nightmare for a cataloger. I learned how to catalog in grad school, and yeah. wow. I cannot imagine if they changed any of my favorite books and thinking it’s a brand new book!

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      Thanks for your comment Nicole. It is especially frustrating when you follow ‘authors’ rather than notice titles. You buy EVERYTHING that a certain author writes, only to find that you have two of the same book.

      Like

  9. I hate it when this happens too. Sometimes the title will change when a book is released in a different country, but with the internet and being able to order books from different countries you have to be careful. It also happens with movie titles. A few times I’ve picked up a dvd then realised I’ve already seen it under a different title.

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      I agree Martin. The internet has made the world so ‘small’ that it seems unnecessary to change titles for different regions. Thanks for your comment.

      Liked by 1 person

  10. M T McGuire says:

    I bought the same Bill Bryson book twice. It’s very annoying.

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      Whew! I guess I’m not the only one who bought the same book twice! It’s funny, I was going to add Bill Bryson’s “Down Under“, but decided to stick to just fiction for my examples. Thanks for commenting.

      Liked by 1 person

  11. I did not know this was such a common thing!! I will definitely have to be more on alert when picking up books.

    Like

  12. It’s funny because I agree – most of the titles and books they discarded I liked better than the ones they changed to!

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      Hope I didn’t mislead you. The titles were not discarded as such. For the most part they are simultaneously being sold on either side of the Atlantic. The publishers seem to think that the markets are SO vastly different, that what is acceptable in the UK is not acceptable in the US/Can. markets. In my humble opinion, readers are not so fickle that they need to be ‘worked’ in this manner by publishers.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Just like the Harry Potter name change. In the UK and Canada we get Philosophers Stone and in the US they got Sorcerers stone. Strange. I don’t really see the difference or need for a change lol. And what I meant by discarded was that they changed it to something regionally appropriate lol I choose the wrong words a lot lol

        Like

  13. Great post and I too find it incredibly annoying, I think perhaps the first title didn’t sell as well as they hoped so they rebranded and tried again. And OMG, how different are the Mindy Mejia covers! I agree the Hattie Hoffman one is much better!
    It happened to me with The Project series by Nikki Owen, book one I read was called Subject 365, but book one is also called The Spider in the Corner of the Room 🙈 It also happens to one of my fav books of last year Method 15/33 or should I say The Method. So frustrating!

    Like

  14. rashthedoctor says:

    tbh I didn’t even know that authors do this , I generally don’t buy a lot of recent new titles , those I do , I do so by consulting with Goodreads or by reading a review by someone who has read the book , and never come across changed title doing so . I do understand it must be annoying though , I must start keeping an eye on books I have on my TBR from now on

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      To be fair, I first became aware of this practice while working at a library. Though, as I said, only this week my first TWO examples were brought to my attention when I requested them for review.

      Liked by 1 person

  15. Susie | Novel Visits says:

    Wow! You’ve rounded up a lot of examples. It is so, so annoying when publishers do this. It must overall pay off for them and I suspect that it’s only really committed readers that ever notice. A person who only reads ten or twelve books a year probably wouldn’t run across two examples of the same story.
    On the same vein, I hate when I see a book being marketed as a new release and then look at it online only to find out it was originally released a year or two ago!
    Fun post!

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      Yes Susie, I agree with your comment about new releases. More times than enough I’ve gotten excited to see a ‘new’ book by one of my favorite authors – only to discover it is an ‘old’ book, repackaged.

      Like

  16. I find it as annoying as you (and I’ve shared your library pains re reservations). I can sort of understand if an older title is re-issued and a publisher might want to give it a more contemporary cover and relevant title. Though even then it should be highlighted on the record entry so anyone buying it is aware. What I don’t get is the change of title for the UK vs US market. Unless you’re going to go through the book and adapt everything else what is the point. Pick a title that is suitable for both like the majority of other authors manage to do. I find some of it quite devious for example when an author ‘takes off’ and the back catalogue that wasn’t so well known is rehashed with a new title so readers assume it’s new. That’s fine is you’ve not read it, but if you’ve been a fan since the beginning it’s annoying. – Rant over, but you did ask 🙂

    Like

    • Fictionophile says:

      I knew you’d share my pain Jill. I agree SO much about your UK vs US/Can market comment. For example British television is immensely popular this side of the Atlantic. We manage to listen and understand British jargon just fine. Why change a title so that it is more ‘understandable’ to the North American market? (as was the case with Ian Rankin’s “Fleshmarket Close”).

      Liked by 1 person

  17. Cathy says:

    So frustrating when that happens. It’s what prompted me to keep a record which in turn lead to my blog.

    Like

  18. Incredibly annoying. Like you, I’ve accidentally purchased the same book twice as the title had changed. I can’t even imagine the nightmare for librarians and booksellers.

    I don’t get the point at all. CD’s don’t change titles whether they’re released in the US or Europe. Why do it with book titles?

    Also agree with you about the Hattie Hoffman cover. I never would have looked at the one on the right.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s